In my view, the real fight of this decade won't be left versus right. Or Washington versus Beijing.
There's a good chance it comes down to two companies. SpaceX and Anthropic.
Two visions of AI. Two visions of humanity.
On one side, SpaceX, which absorbed xAI in February. A simple philosophy. Individual freedom first. Free markets as the engine. Growth as a moral goal. And poverty seen for what it really is: an engineering problem.
Not a redistribution problem. Not a guilt problem. A problem of cost, energy, physics and production.
This is the company that crushed the cost of reaching orbit by making rockets reusable, while the entire industry swore it couldn't be done. That brought the internet to places no government ever bothered to run a cable. And that now wants to put compute in orbit, powered by the sun, so intelligence becomes as abundant as light.
Their answer to risk: build faster, and build better.
On the other side, Anthropic. A different vocabulary. Safety. Regulation. The common good. Protecting democracy.
On paper, it sounds noble. Nobody is against safety.
But look at what it produces in practice. Agencies, licenses, approval queues for every model, rules written alongside the incumbents that only giants can afford to comply with. David Sacks named it back in October 2025: a sophisticated regulatory capture strategy built on fear.
And in September, he asked them the only question that matters: if you really want to slow down, why do you need Washington's permission?
This playbook is as old as markets. Bastiat described it in 1845, with the candlemakers' petition begging the state to protect them from the unfair competition of the sun.
Today the candles are called safety. And the sun is abundant intelligence.
My read: behind the language of the common good sits the defense of inertia. Institutions, rents and legacy systems that have everything to lose if intelligence becomes free and available to any kid in Lagos or in Ohio.
One side wants abundance to belong to everyone.
The other wants to decide who gets it.
Pick your champion.
https://x.com/brivael/status/2123829542238188013?a=79Xea0BPfQ2xYNALRXg&s=20
Nobody has ever regulated fire.
We feared it. We cursed it. We punished those who brought it. But nobody, ever, managed to take it back.
In the myth, Zeus chains Prometheus to a rock for giving fire to humanity. He condemns him for eternity. But look at the detail everyone forgets: Zeus never gets the fire back. He can't. Once it's given, it's everywhere.
Today's fire is intelligence.
And since November 3rd, there's only one word in the air: moratorium. New York has frozen large data centers for a year. Bernie Sanders and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez want a national moratorium. Some are openly calling for a ban on superintelligence.
Let me show you, step by step, why it won't work. Not ideology. Mechanics.
Premise A: a technology that lowers the cost of something essential can't be banned. It relocates.
In the early 15th century, China had the largest fleet in the world. Zheng He's ships reached the coast of East Africa. Then the court shut it all down and kept private maritime trade banned until 1567. The oceans didn't stay empty. They became Portuguese, then Dutch, then English.
Gutenberg was printing around 1450. The first Muslim printer in the Ottoman Empire only got his license in 1727. Two and a half centuries. Meanwhile, Europe printed the Reformation, the Scientific Revolution and the Enlightenment.
In 1865, Britain passed the Locomotive Act: 4 miles per hour on the road, 2 in town, and a man on foot walking ahead of the vehicle with a red flag. Meanwhile, Benz and Daimler invented the automobile in Germany, and Panhard and Peugeot industrialized it in France. The law was repealed in 1896. The lead was gone for good.
The pattern hasn't moved in six centuries: banning a technology doesn't erase it. It only decides who masters it.
Premise B: what's made of information can't be contained.
In the 1990s, Washington classified strong encryption as a munition. Phil Zimmermann, the creator of PGP, spent three years under criminal investigation for "exporting" it. His answer: in 1995, MIT Press printed the entire PGP source code as a book. Books can be exported. Abroad, people scanned it and recompiled it. The investigation was dropped in January 1996. Today, you use strong encryption every time you open a website.
On February 24, 2023, Meta restricted its Llama model to hand-picked researchers. On March 3, it was a torrent on 4chan. On March 10, a developer released llama.cpp and ran it on a laptop. Two weeks from controlled lab to anyone's laptop.
In January 2025, a Chinese lab cut off from the best American chips released DeepSeek R1, with open weights, close to the best models of the moment. Nvidia lost nearly $600 billion in market value in a single session.
They've figured this out, by the way. That's why they're going after data centers and not models: it's the last place where AI still has a body. But a data center blocked in New York gets built in Texas. Blocked in Europe, it gets built in Abu Dhabi. And every year, the same intelligence fits in fewer watts.
Premise C: a system held together by opacity doesn't survive transparency.
In the USSR, photocopiers were under state control. Information was the Party's monopoly. On April 26, 1986, Chernobyl exploded. It was Sweden that detected the radiation. Soviet television waited two days to mention it. In 2006, Gorbachev himself wrote that Chernobyl, even more than perestroika, was perhaps the real cause of the Soviet Union's collapse.
On November 9, 1989, an East German spokesman announced by mistake, at a press conference, that the borders were open effective immediately. West German TV, which the whole East watched, aired it that evening. A few hours later, the Wall was open.
An empire of lies doesn't fall when you attack it. It falls the day verifying becomes cheaper than lying.
Now put it together.
AI is driving the cost of intelligence toward zero: ban it, and it relocates. It's made of information: lock it up, and it leaks. It makes verification free: everything held together by opacity dissolves.
So it won't be banned. The only real choice is where it gets built, and by whom.
So what's left for the takers? For those who lived off permission, gatekeeping and information asymmetry?
Two options. History has already tested both.
Option one: Kodak. In 1975, a Kodak engineer invented the digital camera. Management protected film. In 2012, Kodak filed for bankruptcy.
Option two: the music industry. It shut down Napster in 2001, then spent a decade watching its revenue collapse. It only survived by doing exactly what it had fought: putting all the world's music online. Today, streaming is most of its revenue.
Reinvent yourself, or disappear. There is no third box.
In the Middle Ages, every evening, a bell rang the curfew. The word comes from the French "couvre-feu": cover the fire. Bank the embers for the night. That's all power ever managed to do with fire. Set the hour. Never put it out.
We never banned fire. We invented the forge, the hearth, the steam engine.
Fire can't be banned. It only changes hands.
And this time, it's in everyone's hands.


No comments:
Post a Comment